Summary
- India’s Parliament was envisioned as a temple of the Constitution—a disciplined, rule-bound forum where debate is governed by law, not noise.
- Yet repeated scenes of sloganeering, procedural defiance, and forced adjournments have raised a grave concern: is Parliament being pushed toward disorder and mob-like conduct?
This narrative combines two core arguments:
- Parliament’s constitutional sanctity is being eroded by normalized disruption, and
- Well-defined parliamentary rules already exist—but are being openly violated.
The conclusion is unavoidable: strict, lawful enforcement of procedure is essential to preserve democracy, dignity, and rule of law.
Why Parliamentary Sanctity, Procedure, and Authority Must Be Restored—Firmly and Lawfully
1) Why Parliament Is Called a “Temple of the Constitution”
The Parliament of India is not just another political venue. It is the highest constitutional institution, described as a “temple” because it embodies:
- Supremacy of the Constitution over individuals and parties
- Rule of law over raw power or street pressure
- Procedure over passion and impulse
- Reasoned debate over intimidation and spectacle
Mechanisms like Question Hour, Zero Hour, motions, notices, committee scrutiny, and Budget debates exist to:
- Civilize political conflict
- Demand evidence for allegations
- Protect minority and dissenting voices
- Ensure accountability through records and votes
Without discipline, these safeguards collapse.
2) The Alarming Reality: What Citizens Repeatedly Witness
Across multiple sessions of the Lok Sabha and the Rajya Sabha, a disturbing pattern has become routine:
- The House resumes → instant shouting begins
- No notice, no permission → demands for immediate discussion
- Senior leaders, including the Leader of Opposition, start sloganeering the moment proceedings restart
- Members rush to the Well, physically blocking the House
- Directions from the Chair are ignored
- Repeated adjournments waste entire sittings
This is not democratic protest. It is systematic obstruction.
3) Parliament Is Rule-Bound—Not a Free-for-All
- Parliamentary democracy functions on clear, written procedures. These are not optional customs; they are constitutional safeguards.
The correct process to raise any issue includes:
- Submitting a formal notice to the Secretariat
- Providing supporting facts, records, or documents
- The Chair examining admissibility, urgency, relevance, and duplication
- The matter being taken up only with the Chair’s permission
- Time being allocated so all sides may speak
No Member has the right to begin speaking or shouting without permission.
- Skipping this process is not bold opposition—it is defiance of constitutional procedure.
4) The Chair’s Authority: Central to Parliamentary Survival
- The Chair is the constitutional umpire, not a ceremonial figure.
- The Chair decides what is discussed and when
- Ensures fairness and order
- Protects Members who follow the rules
If the Chair’s authority is undermined:
- Debate turns into chaos
- Rules become meaningless
- Parliament risks becoming ungovernable
A House where the loudest voice prevails is no longer democratic—it is decibel-driven mobocracy.
5) Dissent vs. Disorder: A Red Line Must Be Enforced
The distinction is simple but critical:
Dissent
- Submits notice
- Seeks permission
- Debates, argues, votes
- Records opposition on the floor
Disorder
- Shouts without permission
- Blocks proceedings physically
- Defies the Chair
- Prevents Parliament from functioning
When disorder becomes routine, Parliament begins to resemble a fish market:
- Noise replaces sense
- Volume replaces validity
- Agendas are “sold” by shouting
This is not democracy—it is mob rule inside the legislature.
6) Why This Is Extremely Dangerous for the Republic
Disorder in Parliament causes cascading damage:
- Citizens lose representation when MPs cannot speak
- Governance slows as laws and budgets stall
- Public trust erodes when rules appear optional
- Rule of law weakens when lawmakers violate their own procedures
A legislature that cannot enforce discipline within itself cannot credibly enforce law outside.
7) Rules Without Consequences Invite Chaos
- Rules matter only when violations have costs.
Strict but lawful actions must include:
- Action against Members who raise issues without notice or permission
- Naming and suspension for those who repeatedly disrupt proceedings
- Immediate disciplinary steps for physical obstruction and unruly scenes
- Graduated but firm penalties for serial offenders
This is not silencing opposition.
- It is protecting the collective right of Parliament to function.
8) Law, Judiciary, and Enforcement: No Ambiguity
To restore order:
- Parliamentary rules must be applied consistently, without fear or favour
- The judiciary must clearly distinguish protest from prevention of governance
- House marshals and security must be empowered to maintain order
- Due process must be followed—but without hesitation or selectivity
Firmness within law is democratic strength.
- Hesitation in the face of disorder is constitutional failure.
9) A Simple Constitutional Test
- No discussion without the Chair’s permission.
- No permission without due process.
- No due process without consequences for defiance.
This is not rigidity—it is the minimum discipline required for a functioning democracy.
Reclaiming the Temple of the Constitution
- Parliament has not inherently become a temple of vandalism—but it risks appearing like one when disorder is normalized and procedure is mocked.
A constitutional temple is preserved not by lofty speeches, but by:
- Respect for rules
- Authority of the Chair
- Accountability for unruly conduct
- Public insistence on discipline over drama
The choice before India is clear:
- A marketplace of noise, or
- A temple of the Constitution and the center of rule of law
Democracy does not die in one act of shouting.
- It dies when citizens stop demanding that their highest institution function with dignity, discipline, and constitutional seriousness.
🇮🇳 Jai Bharat, Vandematram 🇮🇳
Read our previous blogs 👉 Click here
Join us on Arattai 👉 Click here
👉Join Our Channels 👈
